Wireless APs

Over the last few months, it’s been disconcerting to see the reported cases of people getting fined (or worse) for using open wireless access points without permission.

I travel frequently and the use of open APs is an important (if not always reliable) way that I get online. Every time my Internet connection at home goes down, I take advantage of one my neighbors APs. To balance things out, I make sure I always run an open AP for others out my home.

There are many smart reasons not to run an open AP but, for me, doing so is about being a good neighbor. I’ve found that even for the most cautious and conservative, most of the serious risks of running an AP can be mitigated by a measured combination of firewalling and monitoring.

The most ridiculous part of this crackdown is not how common and completely normal intentional "transgressive" wireless sharing is but how how often people do it completely unintentionally and without ever knowing.

Once I was in New York City with Micah and Biella and, knowing that we were technically proficient, a member of Biella’s extended family invited us over to help fix his printer which he was unable to print to over his wireless network. What eventually became clear was that his wireless AP was set of incorrectly and had never worked. His laptop couldn’t find the printer because the printer was on his home network and he had, without his knowledge, been using his neighbor’s wireless since he moved in. He had been paying for DSL which he had never actually used.

In densely populated places — New York in particular but any Western city probably falls into this category — this is incredibly common. Punishing people for doing what so many people do completely unintentionally — and almost entirely without negative consequences I might add — would be silly if what was at stake was not so serious.

One thought on “Wireless APs”

  1. Apart from “Punishing people for doing what so many people do completely unintentionally”, which is extraordinarily ridiculous, there is something at what I startled:

    “the use of open APs is an important (if not always reliable) way that I get online”  and “To balance things out, I make sure I always run an open AP for others out my home.”.

    In short, act as a good neighbour or better, as a community. Matter of fact, I’d go even farther, as I told my friend Phil Hughes. THAT should not be an exception, but a rule. I have an AP when I’m connected whereever I am. There is a blackout?. No problem, my neighbour have electricity, so I connect using his AP. That way, everybody is connected at every time, in any circumstance.

    Moreover, if I were in, say, an hotel, people should conenct at anytime, without ANY registration. You have to have, as you say, firewalling and monitoring. A kid studies in a public school?. OK, they have a Wifi antenna nearby, so they connect to the Internet instantly (OK this is a different case, you should use some filtering software, like Edubuntu will do).

    I believe this idea would be liked by Mark Shuttleworth, especially regarding South Africa (and many other countries)…

    Best regards.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>